Which college would my best fit for football be?

I was in a similar position to you i was recruited by only a couple of small schools, problem for me was that they were all D-3 which as you probably know don't offer athletic scholarships, and since many D-3 schools are small private schools they can be very expensive. The 2 schools that i talked to really seriously had a tuition of like 30000 dollars. So you are going to want to go with the D-2 route preferably just because its better quality football that NAIA, NAIA 2nd choice and D-3 if those 2 don't end up working out. And by the way i didnt end up playing college football at all, just couldn't afford it, i joined the navy instead. And lastly don't just wait for coaches to contact you, contact them, recruiting budgets at small schools aren't real big so there are plenty of good players that they just dont find.